CAS 2023/A/9451 - CAS 2023/A/9455 - CAS 2023/A/9456 – Page 20
49. On or shortly after 22 March 2022, the FMBA provided to RUSADA (in an undated
letter) details of the medications and supplements prescribed by the FMBA in the period
1 January 2020 to 31 December 2021 as follows:
“[I]n the period from 01.01.2020 to 31.12.2021 the athlete Kamila Valieva was given
the following medications, sports nutrition and dietary supplements by the Center’s
doctors Mr Adamov, Mr Shvetskiy and Mr Shumakov: Amino Vital Multi Energy,
Stimol, oral injection solution, Magnelis B6, Vitrum Superstress, Panangin Forte,
Hypoxen capsules, L-Carnitine, fluid Mg complex, Kreon, Flitrum-STI, Imudon,
Polyoxidonium, Ibuclin, Versatis plaster, Sustamin, Nimesulid, Traumeel S, Supadryn,
ISODRINX, Orthomol Sport, Geladrink, Agisept, Grippferon, Doppelhertz aktiv,
CoQ10, Glycine, Tot’hema, Ketrolac, Sorbifer Durules, Riboxin, Berocca Plus,
Gorpils, Maxilac, Omega 3, Stimol, Amino Vital, Bilactin, Diara, Metoclopramide,
Voltaren, Junior Active Complex, SportExpert, BCAA+, Esslial Forte, Amino Vital
Gold, Aspirin C, Valmedin drops, Guarana 300, Carmolis lolly, Coldrex Maksgrip,
Creatine Ox, Xylometazoline, Tot’hema, Cytovlavin pills, Tilaxine, Calcimine Advance,
Imudon, Hypoxen, Alfa Normix, ACC … .”
50. On 30 March 2022, RUSADA interviewed Ms Tutberidze, who also provided a written
statement, a summary of which is as follows:
a. Ms Tutberidze has been coaching Ms Valieva since 2018.
b. Mr Gleykhengauz and Mr Dudakov have also been coaching her since that time.
c. The doctors providing medical support to Ms Valieva were Dr Shumakhov and
Dr Adamov. Dr Shvetskiy is a “mobile doctor of the national figure skating team
assigned to my group of the athletes”; he goes to the competitions with the team.
Dr Ozerov is in charge of the admission of the athletes to the competitions and
for the organisation of the medical examination by the FMBA.
d. As a coach, Ms Tutberidze “do[es] not control and do[es] not discuss with the
team doctors the medications and supplements, which are given to the athletes
of the team”.
e. Ms Valieva did not complain about any problems with her heart except in March
2021 when the FMBA recommended, upon a detailed medical examination, that
she decrease her workload.
f. Ms Tutberidze was aware that Dr Shvetskiy had been accused of violating anti-
doping rules but did not consider this an issue given that “he does not manage
the medical treatment and provide medical support to the athletes but organizes
the additional medical observation, consultations as well as escorts the team to
the competitions as a sports doctor for the provision of the first aid”. The
Russian Figure Skating Federation had no objections regarding the appointment
of Dr Shvetskiy as a team doctor.